Planning your job

How to Compare Handyman Quotes: Free Side-by-Side Worksheet

Compare up to three handyman quotes line by line with our free worksheet: scope, materials, pricing, fees, cleanup, licensed-trade work, warranty and insurance.

Mendexo Editorial Team
Mendexo Editorial Team
Illustration of a handyman going over plans and material samples with two homeowners at a table

Start with the same job list for everyone

Quotes only compare well when every handyman prices the same work. Send each one the same written list, with photos, measurements, the wall type and who supplies the parts.

Ask for the price in writing. A text or email is fine if it lists each job. A single number with no detail is hard to compare and easy to dispute later.

Compare three quotes with the worksheet

Enter up to three quotes below. For each line, mark it Included, Excluded or Not stated, and add notes. Then press the button to see the questions to ask each handyman. Nothing you type leaves this page.

Free planning tool

Compare three handyman quotes side by side

Put the quotes side by side. Mark what’s included and see which questions still need an answer.

No account needed · Your entries stay in this page

What to compare
01Scope of work and assumptions
02Materials and who supplies them
03Hourly or fixed price, and minimum charge
04Trip or call-out fee
05Prep, protection and cleanup
06Removal and disposal
07Permits and licensed-trade work left out
08Workmanship warranty
09Insurance
10Total price, taxes and payment terms
Keep anything unclear as ‘Not stated’.

What each line means

  • Scope of work and assumptions: every job on your list, plus anything the handyman assumed, such as the wall being drywall.
  • Materials and who supplies them: parts, brands and models, and whether they are in the price or extra.
  • Hourly or fixed price, and minimum charge: a fixed price per job is easiest to compare. For hourly quotes, ask for the expected hours and a cap.
  • Trip or call-out fee: HomeGuide puts US trip charges at $30 to $80.
  • Prep, protection and cleanup: moving furniture, covering floors and cleaning up dust.
  • Removal and disposal: taking away packaging, old fixtures or debris.
  • Permits and licensed-trade work: which parts need a permit or a licensed electrician, plumber or gas engineer, and who arranges that.
  • Workmanship warranty: how long the handyman guarantees the work, and what it covers.
  • Insurance: whether the handyman carries liability insurance, with a certificate if you ask.
  • Total price, taxes and payment terms: the full price with tax, the deposit, when the rest is due and how extra work is approved.

Check the price against typical ranges

Once the lines match, compare the totals. Use typical prices as a check, not a target. For example, cost guides put US TV mounting at $120 to $250 (Housecall Pro), and a drywall patch at $120 to $350 and a faucet replacement at $100 to $300 (Angi). See the full table in how much a handyman costs in 2026.

A much lower quote is not always a bad one, but ask what it leaves out. A much higher quote may include things the others skipped, such as materials or painting.

Red flags in a quote

  • Only a total, with no list of jobs.
  • Electrical, gas or plumbing work in the quote without saying who is licensed to do it. See what a handyman can legally do.
  • A large deposit before any materials are bought.
  • No way to approve extra work before it is done.
  • A deadline to accept the price today.

Next step

Choose the quote that is clearest, covers your whole list and fits your budget. Then confirm the details in writing. Our hiring checklist lists the questions to ask before work starts.